Twenty-six years in the past immediately, Deep Space Nine delivered the knife underneath its cloaked examination of Star Trek’s morals in wartime with all the fragile precision of a stitching needle: the unbelievable “Within the Pale Moonlight,” not simply one in all DS9 or Star Trek’s finest hours, however one of many all time best episodes of TV ever made. However the best second in an already immaculate piece of tv is all in regards to the methods to enact violence with out lifting a single finger.
“Within the Pale Moonlight,” framed round a maudlin Captain Sisko recounting latest occasions in his private log after a protracted, lengthy day, is in regards to the rising ethical compromises he’s keen to make as one in all Starfleet’s vanguards within the increasingly dire war in opposition to the Dominion. Seeing a possibility to deliver one of many Federation’s coldest enemies, the secretive Romulans, right into a warfare they’ve stayed impartial in, Sisko finds himself drawn into the charismatic orbit of the straightforward tailor and sometimes grasp of all types of spycraft, Garak the Cardassian clothier, as the 2 plot to artificially assemble proof of a Dominion plot to invade the Romulan Star Empire, and cross it alongside to a Romulan senator.
The episode layers on its rigidity by way of every circle of hell Sisko is keen to place his soul by way of. Even step one of merely working with Garak on such a plan is already heinous sufficient for the excessive and mighty values of Starfleet’s officer class, however little by little, Sisko begins to see the proverbial river of blood he should wade into to come back out of the opposite facet with even a probability of Romulus getting into the Dominion Warfare. Utilizing criminals to pretend proof, crafting the right deception, planting it in Senator Vreenak’s arms, all this could be tantamount to the gravest of ethical prices our hero may pay… after which all of it blows up in his face when Vreenak calls Sisko out on his bluff, realizing the information rod he’s been handed showcasing the Dominion’s supposed plans is counterfeit.
It’d be right here that another Star Trek present would plant its flag because the lowest second one in all its heroes may sink to: they performed soiled, and now should face the implications of taking the low street. However Deep House 9 is not any other Star Trek show, and so it prepares to thrust its knife. The following day, as senior employees monitor casualty lists and Sisko braces for his fall, a Starfleet Intelligence report comes by way of confirming the demise of a Romulan Senator in a shuttlecraft explosion the Star Empire is laying by the hands of Dominion subterfuge. It’s Vreenak: he’s useless, the key of Sisko’s ethical price with him, and Sisko is aware of precisely who’s guilty for the explosion.
As Sisko storms all the way down to Garak’s store, we get it: the best second in all of Deep Space Nine. Time and time once more within the present, in methods small and enormous, we’ve seen up up to now that Benjamin Sisko is just not a person who pulls punches, metaphorically or in any other case. From laying out Q the second he tries to forged the then-Commander as one other Picard, to his dogged willpower to root out the anti-Cardassian guerrillas of the Maquis, Sisko has all the time acted as he does right here: to come back in swinging. He decks Garak, sending him clear throughout the room. He yells his accusations at Garak—he killed Vreenak, he killed the felony they used to forge that knowledge rod; all alongside, he’s knowingly introduced the Romulans into the deadliest warfare the Alpha Quadrant has seen in generations on a falsehood. Even with out the punch, this isn’t Sisko passionate or dogged or decided. He’s livid, one thing we’ve got seen simmering in him earlier than, however now absolutely unleashed.
However Garak by no means fights again. He takes Sisko’s punch, and all the fad, goes to dam the second swing, however he doesn’t match Sisko’s braggadocio. He waits. After which in chilly, calculating kind, he turns Sisko on himself—laying out all of the proof that the Romulans will now have, from a useless senator to an imperfect, broken rod containing even the faintest traces of proof of a Dominion plot, and guides Sisko alongside the way in which to a conclusion that was there from the start of the episode. Sisko would see what Garak predicts the Romulans will see, and would enter the war against the Dominion, simply as they’ll. Garak doesn’t even must say it, he simply lets Sisko work by way of it out loud himself, not even having to push him… as a result of for all his posture, for all of the fists swinging, they assume precisely the identical. And if something, Sisko is even dirtier than that, as a result of he already knew that in going to Garak he would get somebody who keen to soiled their very own arms on his behalf, and go away him with the victory he needed—at any price, it doesn’t matter what he’d declare in any other case.
And so, with Sisko on the lowest depths of hell ultimately, he and Garak are locked as kindred spirits on this sport of spycraft and ethical theater. It’s a exceptional second, one which has rightly caught with Star Trek for the 2 and a half many years because it first broadcast, due to the way in which it skewers the franchise’s legacy of purported enlightenment in such an elegantly compelling way. For years earlier than this, Starfleet and its officers have been depicted as above this sort of underhanded manipulation—that our heroes speak their methods out of fights, that they keep the ethical excessive floor, and that even once they falter, once they play slightly soiled, it’s with a roguish attraction, and within the method of a hero, the small, harmless costs paid, for a better good that’s all the time price it. It’s by no means meant to stain their soul, as a result of ultimately, it all the time works out within the hero’s favor—and their righteous view of the universe.
Sisko’s better good is a whole lot of 1000’s, if not tens of millions, of beings slaughtered to stop the whole destruction of the Alpha Quadrant powers as we all know them, predicated on a lie. In the long run, he bought it, not within the noblest of manners because the heroes earlier than him might need, however by way of cloak and dagger deception and knives at the hours of darkness. As a result of, again in opposition to the wall, he was all the time keen to throw that punch—and since Garak knew it too, he himself by no means needed to.
Need extra io9 information? Take a look at when to anticipate the newest Marvel, Star Wars, and Star Trek releases, what’s subsequent for the DC Universe on film and TV, and all the things you have to find out about the way forward for Doctor Who.
